Sen. John Fetterman is once again proving to be one of the strangest figures in today’s Democratic Party, a maverick from Pennsylvania who keeps irritating the left while earning unexpected praise from Republican voters.
During a prerecorded interview on “My View with Lara Trump” that aired Saturday, Fetterman admitted [1] he still does not quite understand why so many Republicans seem to like him.
“I go everywhere. I do most of a lot of the shopping. And people will approach me, and it’s almost uniformly very positive,” Fetterman said.
The Pennsylvania Democrat added, “I can’t fully understand, I’ve seen polling, why I’m so popular with Republicans. I don’t really understand that, but I’m always going to treat both sides with respect.”
WATCH:
That sentence alone probably explains half of the mystery.
In a Democratic Party where calling Republicans fascists has practically become a nervous tic, basic courtesy now qualifies as political rebellion.
Fetterman stressed that he refuses to describe Republicans as Nazis or fascists, saying disagreements should be handled with respect.
Imagine that, a United States senator suggesting political opponents are not comic book villains.
His numbers with Pennsylvania voters show just how upside down the current political map has become.
A recent Quinnipiac University poll found Fetterman with a 77 percent approval rating among Republicans in the state, while Democrats gave him a 69 percent disapproval rating.
That kind of split would have been almost unthinkable a generation ago.
Today, it makes perfect sense in a party where the loudest voices seem more interested in campus protest slogans than normal working class voters.
Lara Trump told Fetterman the Republican Party would “love” to have him switch sides.
The senator, however, rejected the offer, at least for now.
“My whole family is Republican, and I think they love me,” Fetterman quipped, adding that his father was watching the interview.
He said his criticism is aimed at the most extreme forces inside his own party, not at everyday Democrats.
“My criticism is directed at the extreme, in my view, indefensible kinds of views [of] things,” Fetterman said.
He also warned about primary candidates in his party who keep moving further left on Israel and America.
“People that are winning the primaries, they are almost always anti Israel and then anti American, and they’ve been forced to delete all the outlandish things that they’ve said,” he said.
Fetterman has repeatedly broken with his party’s activist wing through his firm defense of Israel.
That stance has made him a target for the left, where support for America’s closest Middle East ally is apparently now treated as some exotic right wing habit.
He has also clashed with Democrats during government shutdown fights, refusing to simply follow the party line when he believes the left is playing games with basic governance.
For voters tired of performative outrage, that sort of bluntness has obvious appeal.
Republicans have noticed.
Senate Majority Leader John Thune of South Dakota and others have reportedly made overtures to Fetterman, hoping he might consider leaving the Democratic Party.
Fetterman has repeatedly said he is not switching parties.
Still, he has left himself one notable caveat, suggesting that if Democrats become aggressively hostile to Israel, that could change the equation.
That answer should make Democratic strategists a little nervous, assuming they still have time between scolding voters and chasing approval from online activists.
WATCH:
Fetterman may not be a conservative, but he has learned that the hard left has a very low tolerance for dissent.
Despite his reputation as a thorn in the side of progressives, GovTrack has ranked Fetterman as more liberal than more than a dozen Senate Democrats based on his voting record.
In other words, Republicans are not cheering him because he suddenly became Barry Goldwater.
They are responding to something simpler.
He talks like a human being, shows up in places outside the left wing media bubble, and refuses to pretend that every Republican voter is a threat to civilization.
Fetterman also complained about what he sees as a double standard inside the Democratic coalition.
Far left politicians can attack moderate Democrats all day long, but when he criticizes the extreme wing, the outrage machine starts spinning.
“There’s also been a double standard. People, whether it’s [Bernie] Sanders or other people, are allowed to criticize Democrats, but when I call out the extreme … I get the criticism like ‘why are you going on Fox?’” Fetterman said.
“I’ll have a conversation with anyone that’s going to play it straight as you and Fox has,” he added.
WATCH:
That is the real offense in the eyes of the modern left.
Not just that Fetterman criticizes them, but that he is willing to sit down with people they have declared off limits.
For now, Fetterman remains a Democrat, much to the disappointment of Republicans hoping for a dramatic party switch.
But his popularity with GOP voters is no mystery to anyone paying attention.
When one Democrat declines to spit venom at half the country, defends Israel without apology, and calls out the radicals in his own backyard, Americans notice.
These days, that is apparently enough to make him sound like a rebel.