Director Chris Columbus has reopened an uncomfortable chapter in the making of “Home Alone,” revealing that one actor performed so poorly during a screen test that Columbus fired him from the hit film. Columbus said he was “just awful.”
As Page Six reported [1], Columbus made the blunt disclosure during a Tuesday appearance on the “Wildmen” podcast. He said the performer remains the only person he has ever had to dismiss from a project.
At the time, the studio “wouldn’t pay” for Daniel Stern, who ultimately played burglar Marv. That prompted the production to test another actor opposite Joe Pesci, who portrayed Harry Lime.
“I mean, Pesci was great. This other kid was, and he was a kid at the time, he was just awful. And I had to — that’s the only person I ever had to fire,” Columbus said of the unnamed actor.
The director said he still tried to leave the possibility of a future collaboration open when he fired the performer. Despite that suggestion, Columbus acknowledged that the two never worked together afterward.
Columbus did not identify the actor on the podcast. Entertainment Weekly reported that the performer was Daniel Roebuck, who had previously confirmed that he was removed from “Home Alone” after only four days.
Page Six contacted representatives for both Columbus and Roebuck for comment.
Stern later secured the role of Marv and appeared alongside Pesci in the original 1990 movie. Both returned for the 1992 sequel, “Home Alone 2: Lost in New York.”
Roebuck had already discussed his short time on the production during a 2023 appearance on the “What a Character!” podcast. In his account, he insisted that the role was never truly going to be his.
“I was never gonna be Marv,” he said at the time. “Now that’s the one thing they never say. I was never ever ever going to film as Marv.”
Roebuck also recalled a discouraging meeting with writer and producer John Hughes. “I got the wettest handshake of my life with [writer and producer] John Hughes. It was the most disappointing handshake I ever received because I was a fan of the guy. And he clearly didn’t want me to be there. It was all so obvious,” he said.
According to Roebuck, Columbus offered hope even as he let him go. Roebuck said the director suggested they could reunite for another project, but that proposed collaboration never materialized.
“Chris Columbus said I will give you a great part of my next movie,” Roebuck said. “Now, I notice he’s done 20 since then, and he’s never called. But what really was disappointing was, you know, no one ever just told me the truth.”
The recollections meet on one key point: Columbus floated the idea of working together later, and that did not happen. Columbus framed the firing as a singular event in his career, while Roebuck emphasized the disappointment of not receiving a direct explanation.
The part eventually remained closely tied to Stern, who played Marv in both films named in the report. Pesci likewise appeared in the original and sequel as Harry Lime.
News of the old casting turmoil arrives as another entry in the franchise may be moving forward. Earlier this summer, People reported that a new “Home Alone” was in the early stages of development.
“It’s just an idea and an almost green light from Disney,” a source told the outlet in July.
The latest discussion places the bruising casting story back in view, with Columbus publicly calling the performance awful and Roebuck’s earlier comments describing the firing as an experience clouded by disappointment.