New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Amazon are locked in a fierce fight over legislation that the company says could leave consumers paying more for deliveries. The dispute centers on the Delivery Protection Act being pursued by Mamdani’s administration and the New York City Council.
According to The Wall Street Journal, the legislation would require any company operating a warehouse in the city to comply with requirements that Mamdani’s City Hall considers necessary. The proposal would place a heavier regulatory hand over warehouse and delivery operations.
The bill would also require Amazon to convert contractors who deliver its packages into company employees. Mamdani has brushed [1] aside Amazon’s objections to the proposal as “greed.”
Amazon answered Thursday by taking its case directly to New York City customers. People visiting the company’s site were greeted by a popup warning, “NYC Council Could add up to $5 per order.”
The company also warned that the proposed legislation could upend its relationships with existing contractors. “If this legislation passes, we’d no longer be able to work with them, and we’d be forced to consider moving our operations outside of the city,” Amazon’s in-app message said, according to CNBC.
.@NYCMayor Zohran Mamdani, nobody is forced to shop at Amazon. If consumers don’t like the additional delivery charges resulting from your legislation, they can shop elsewhere. They might even discover that competing retailers charge more.
That’s called competition.
Now explain something else.
Your own city government hires outside contractors to deliver packages, documents and other materials. NYC reportedly uses some 85 delivery and logistics contractors.
But when Amazon uses outside delivery companies, suddenly it’s exploitation and corporate greed?
Why doesn’t NYC hire all its delivery workers directly?
Or is outsourcing only bad when private businesses do it?
— Sam E. Antar (@SamAntar) November 19, 2026 [2]
Amazon said moving operations outside New York City could carry consequences for customers, businesses, and workers. “That would likely mean slower and more expensive delivery for millions of customers in New York City, while also threatening small businesses and their thousands of employees,” the company said.
Amazon representative Kelly Nantel said the warning was intended to tell customers what the legislation could cost them if approved in its current form. The company is also urging concerned customers to contact their representatives on the City Council.
“As the City Council continues to review this bill, we want to be transparent with our customers about what it would cost them if it passes as written, which is why we’re doing this,” Nantel said, according to the Journal.
Nantel also encouraged New Yorkers to speak directly to council members. “If customers are concerned, one of the most impactful things they can do is contact their City Council member and ask them to oppose this bill,” Nantel said.
NY Democrats: Let’s pass a bill to make all deliveries $5 more expensive
Amazon: Deliveries are about to get $5 more expensive
NY Democrats: Jeff Bezos is attacking us!
— Matt Whitlock (@MattWhitlock) November 20, 2026 [3]
Amazon is providing customers with a prepared message opposing Intro 518. The message says, “As your constituent, I am writing to urge you to oppose Intro 518, a bill that threatens to raise costs for New Yorkers like me. This bill could increase my annual delivery costs by up to $664 per year. In a city already facing an affordability crisis, that’s money I cannot afford to lose — and neither can my neighbors.”
The appeal quickly generated a substantial response from customers. Amazon said about 60,000 messages opposing the bill were sent during the first 36 hours after the popup appeared.
City Council Speaker Julie Menin rejected Amazon’s warnings about the proposal. She insisted the law would not affect prices or jobs, according to the Journal, putting the council’s position directly at odds with the company’s claims.
Wow. I genuinely did not suspect she was this dumb. From here:
1) Amazon adds NYC-only surcharge to try to maintain profitability after socialists force unions into its distribution chain.
2) People are outraged.
2) City Council outlaws the surcharge.
3) Amazon stops delivering to New Yorkers. We’re already the only ones who don’t have Walmart.
4) Affordability!— Kyle Smith (@rkylesmith) November 19, 2026 [4]
Amazon countered that the legislation would put jobs “at risk without improving safety,” according to CNBC. The company argued that its current contractor arrangement works because local business owners are closely connected to the communities where they operate.
The company defended that model in pointed terms. It said the system is effective “because local entrepreneurs, people rooted in their communities, deliver a better experience. They invest in their teams, their routes, and their neighborhoods. That’s not a liability play.”
It feels demeaning to even have to explain this, but:
Amazon is *valued by investors* at about $2.8 trillion, which means they’re willing to buy, say, a 1% ownership share for $28 billion. It does not mean they have a $2.8 trillion pile of gold coins. It’s based on the value of expected future profits. It’s a prediction, not a tangible thing.
Amazon’s *profit margins* are extremely low. The consumer marketplace (how most people interact with amazon) has margins around 4%. (Amazon Web Services has a much higher margin, but almost all their customers are other giant corporations that Mamdani also hates). Furthermore, much of that marketplace revenue is advertising. Stripping this out, direct, conventional margins on Amazon sold products are essentially zero. Think about what that means: Amazon found a way to run a business delivering goods to consumer’s doors at cost. They’ve already achieved the communist dream for regular consumers: giving you what you want, overnight, at cost. And they make a profit at the same time!
How can they be worth so much on margins that thin? Scale! They serve hundreds of millions of consumers, so making even small amounts per consumer translates into a giant total figure.
But that also means that any reduction in their tiny margins tanks the entire business overnight. If government regulation turns the tiny fraction of profit they skim off their huge gross revenue from positive to negative (which, again, would require only a couple-percent tax) then suddenly that entire fraction of their business becomes worthless overnight. Investors leave, amazon shrinks to being just a cloud services provider, and Americans can no longer get overnight delivery of literally anything on Earth – AT COST – overnight. The reason for the investor valuations -expected future profits – collapses, and their is no dragon hoard of gold coins to loot anymore. Poof. You won’t have redistributed trillions. You’ll have deleted it from existence.
It’s not that Mamdani doesn’t understand this, or that he does. He doesn’t have a worldview at all. He is a rhetoric machine designed to optimize his personal power. He doesn’t know or care about the concepts of “outcomes” or “consequences”. The final form of a politician in a mass democracy.
— Hunter Ash (@ArtemisConsort) November 20, 2026 [5]
The bill has backing from unions, including the International Brotherhood of Teamsters. The Teamsters have been trying for years to unionize delivery and warehouse employees, while Amazon continues warning that the proposed overhaul could burden customers and threaten existing businesses and jobs.