WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
  • The Third Circuit denied Rep. LaMonica McIver’s request for a rehearing, leaving two criminal charges cleared to proceed.
  • Only three of the 13 participating judges voted to rehear the case before the full court.
  • Prosecutors allege McIver struck two federal officers during a confrontation surrounding Newark Mayor Ras Baraka’s arrest.
  • The three charges carry a combined maximum sentence of 17 years, while McIver and her lawyers weigh their options.

A federal appeals court on Thursday rejected Rep. LaMonica McIver’s request for a rehearing in the criminal case stemming from her confrontation with federal officers at an ICE detention center in Newark. The decision leaves two criminal charges against the New Jersey Democrat cleared to proceed.

Only three of the 13 Third Circuit judges who participated voted to rehear the case before the full court. The result preserves an August ruling concerning the charges tied to the encounter with federal officers.

In that August ruling, the Third Circuit directed a lower court to reconsider whether a third charge against McIver should be dismissed. The two other charges were allowed to move forward after the appeals court rejected the argument that the alleged conduct was constitutionally protected legislative activity.

McIver, identified as a Democrat representing New Jersey, said she and her lawyers were considering their options following Thursday’s order. Her response sharply criticized the Justice Department and accused it of targeting her over her work involving ICE oversight.

Trump's Sovereign Wealth Fund: What Could It Mean For Your Money?

McIver claimed the prosecution could expose her to 17 years in prison. She also warned that the appeals court’s decision moved the country closer to allowing a president to imprison political opponents.

“Because of a weaponized Department of Justice and because I dared to do my job and conduct oversight of ICE, I am facing 17 years in prison. Now, due to the disappointing decision by the Third Circuit, we are all one step closer to a world in which the president of the United States can try to imprison people simply because he does not like what they stand for.”

The combined maximum sentence for all three charges is 17 years in prison. Each of the two counts permitted to proceed carries a maximum sentence of eight years, while the third charge carries a maximum of one year.

The criminal case traces back to a May 9, 2025, visit to Delaney Hall. McIver and two other House members had gone to the Newark facility to conduct an inspection while an immigration protest was unfolding outside.

FREE Gun Law Map: Laws Don't Pause During Social Unrest

Should Election Day be a federal holiday?

By completing the poll, you agree to receive emails from Objectivist.co, occasional offers from our partners and that you've read and agree to our privacy policy and legal statement.

According to the Justice Department, Newark Mayor Ras Baraka arrived after the lawmakers had already entered a secured area. A federal officer told Baraka that he was not authorized to be there and warned that he would be arrested if he remained.

Baraka subsequently left the fenced area, but agents moved to arrest him after his departure from that space. Federal prosecutors later dropped the trespassing charge that had been brought against the Newark mayor.

The confrontation surrounding Baraka’s arrest became the basis for the allegations against McIver. Prosecutors contend that the congresswoman struck two federal officers during the clash over the mayor’s arrest.

Those allegations form the two counts that the Third Circuit allowed to proceed. In its August ruling, the court determined that the conduct alleged in those counts was outside the Constitution’s protections for legislative acts.

The constitutional question was important to McIver’s effort to stop the charges from moving forward. The Third Circuit’s ruling distinguished the alleged physical conduct during the confrontation from protected legislative activity connected to the lawmakers’ inspection.

Thursday’s order did not grant McIver another hearing before the full appeals court. With only three of the 13 participating judges voting for a rehearing, the prior decision concerning the two counts remains in place.

The third count was treated differently in the August decision. Rather than resolving its dismissal outright, the Third Circuit instructed the lower court to reconsider whether that charge should be thrown out.

McIver and the other two House members continued with their visit following the encounter. They went on to tour Delaney Hall after the confrontation involving Baraka and the federal officers.

The ruling leaves McIver facing two charges carrying possible sentences of up to eight years each, while the third count carries up to one year. She and her attorneys are now weighing their options after failing to secure a rehearing before the full Third Circuit.

The opinions expressed by contributors and/or content partners are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Objectivist. Contact us for guidelines on submitting your own commentary.